Untitled Document
Among different modes of imparting education, Open and Distance Learning (ODL)
has become the best option in the development of higher education. Most countries
have experienced new problems and multidimensional challenges in the process of
its implementation. One of the most challenging tasks was to assist organisations
and its workforce to impart on the job skills without dislodging/disrupting from
their normal employment.
Although open and distance learning has proved efficient in training people for
formal qualifications, provision of professional skills through open and distance
learning has not been given a serious thought as these skills are provided through
face to face teaching/learning methods in the form of short courses. Since the
face to face method could only manage a limited number of participants, it is
essential to use ODL technologies and assist large number of people.
In most developing countries especially in Africa there is a shortage of professional
skills needed in the economy. Botswana is not an exception as it depends on
foreigners for scarce skills needed. There is a growing demand for short courses
to upgrade/refresh the skills of work force. The rapid changes witnessed in
information technologies should accommodate the needs of all clientele especially
the working force.
In the context of offering short term courses in Botswana for skills promotion
of the work force, the paper analyses the following:
- Distance education scenario in Botswana
- Significance of ODL for promotion of professional skills
- Ongoing professional development programmes and their delivery by different
institutions, and
- Strategy for the provision of professional skills through ODL in Botswana.
While explaining the significance of ODL for promotion of skills and the need
for strengthening professional development programmes, the focus of the paper
is to analyse how the new technologies can be used to access this training in
an unlimited way across all regions in the country. The proposed strategy has
to provide training avenues and thereby increasing base level skills of people
in different sectors of the economy. This would in turn, lead to professional
development of individuals and economic development of the country.
DISTANCE EDUCATION SCENARIO IN BOTSWANA
The importance of distance education in Botswana was recognized as early as
1966. The need was felt looking at the general level of educational opportunities
at primary, secondary and higher education levels.
In Botswana, distance education started at two levels, one as a consumer and
another as a provider of distance education. The teachers in Botswana received
training from Zimbabwe between 1960 and 1965 (Jones 1979). This facilitated
to train about 48% untrained teachers in Botswana (Jones 1981). During 1977,
the National Commission on Education reviewed the situation and recommended
the necessary provisions to develop education in both formal and non-formal
set up. Later in 1978, the Department of Non Formal Education (DNFE) was established
in the Ministry of Education, and started functioning as a Distance Education
Division (DED) of the DNFE. This Unit aimed at out-of-school education at Junior
and Senior Secondary levels by distance mode. In 1986 Botswana became the provider
of distance education through a project to upgrade 700 teachers (Jones 1979)
which was considered as successful attempt and the same initiative led to the
establishment of Botswana Extension College (BEC).
In 1994 the Institute of Health Sciences (HIS) started the distance education
programme to upgrade the qualifications of nurses in the Ministry of Health
(Moesi and Mmolawa 1998). At the same time, the University of Botswana has also
involved in distance education through its Institute of Adult Education (IAE).
Although IAE was divided into Department of Adult Education and Centre for Continuing
Education (CCE) formally in 1991, the CCE became active in programming since
1994. Within CCE, Distance Education Unit (DEU) was established with the responsibility
of developing distance education programmes at tertiary level.
The government of Botswana in 1999 established Botswana College of Distance
and Open and Learning (BOCODOL) to take care of pre-tertiary education in the
country through distance mode. At the moment the DEU of the University of Botswana
and the BOCODOL are working hand in hand in the development of distance education
in the country. But the aforesaid institutions have only targeted towards development
of formal education and not much has happened in the area of development of
short term courses to impart on the job skills which is essential to reduce
the government exchequer on hiring skills from other countries by paying higher
emoluments. Although some institutions in Botswana have been running these short
term courses on a full time basis by taking work force out of the job, it is
not meeting the growing demand for these skills. Hence there is need to develop
the programmes by using different ODL technologies which will assist masses
and yield expected results.
SIGNIFICANCE OF ODL FOR PROFESSIONAL SKILLS PROMOTION
The ODL has been accepted as a viable, cost effective and flexible mode of imparting
education across the globe. This approach has been very much successful in the
formal sector. With regard to promotion of soft skills to the working force,
some institutions in Botswana started offering short courses on a regular basis.
In fact these courses have been helping the nation in promoting on the job skills
to a very limited number of clientele. As it was illustrated earlier, not enough
work has been done in the area of providing soft skills through ODL. It is important
that Open and distance education institutions have to increase their access
to professional skills for a larger segment of population through multi-media
instructional system. At preset there are few institutions that are running
the short training programmes in the formal way. In their mission to reach out
to the masses, the institutions have to start introducing different technology
in the delivery process to make the learners comfortable and to receive education
at a convenient time and place as dictated by the learner. Hence the role of
ODL technologies in the delivery process is imminent and thus become economical,
flexible and user friendly to its clientele. .
With the advent and advancement in communication technology, the offering of
short courses should be treated as a priority to the Government in conserving
its resources. A variety of teaching technologies have emerged in ODL. Teaching
through Radio, Audio and video are considered as old technologies where as video
conferencing and computer teaching is high tech/new modes (A.W Bates 1995).
The new technology enables the learners to do courses offered from any part
of the world with out moving out from their homes.
Since the demand for ODL to offer short courses is seen clearly, the concerned
institutions should adopt different modes of delivery starting from print manuals
to the high tech video conferencing and on-line training . The modes of delivery
have to be selected depending on the nature of programme and its target group
not only to compete with one another but also to become more learner centred.
In the context of Botswana, the provision of professional skills is mainly
done by some parastatal and private organizations. The question is how to offer
them on a large scale and assist all groups of people without any discrimination
by way of rural/urban population as these skills are required by every one to
earn their livelihood. Most of the requirement is seen in working groups and
also those who could not attend to formal system due to heavy cost, distance,
time and age factors. Since the country’s population is wide spread geographically,
the significance of ODL as a mode of delivery is important. Further, most of
the clientele would prefer to acquire these skills at their own pace, time,
location, etc. It was observed that majority of learners who have been taking
these courses form different organizations are from working force. And the indications
coming from rural advisory committees suggest that the people need these skills
for self employment and informal sector employment purposes.
The Government is also committed to increase budget for training manpower as
long as it creates skilled human capital in the country and reduces the cost
of hiring skills from other advanced countries. Since the learners are spread
over different geographical locations, the video conferencing technology will
help to promote cost effective and quality education with easy understanding
signals.
ONGOING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMMES IN BOTSWANA
At present there are quite a few institutions that offer professional training
programmes in Botswana. As the demand for these programmes has been on increasing
trend, some private institutions have also started offering these courses. The
institutions that offer professional training programmes are:
- Centre for Continuing Education, University of Botswana
- Botswana National Productivity Centre
- Institute of Development Management
- ILO project -Business skills programmes
- In-service training programmes by respective organisations
The range and frequency of the programmes vary between these institutions depending
on their resource capacity . Almost all institutions use a similar mode of instruction
in the training programmes i.e. face to face instruction. These institutions
were unable to cope with the demand that comes from employers’ of different
organizations. Hence need to develop a new strategy to meet the increasing demand.
The programmes that are generally run by the above institutions are:
- Customer Care and Professional Excellence
- Dial-a-Smile(for Receptionists)
- Training of Trainers
- Supervisory Skills
- Communication Skills
- Occupational Health and safety
- Mentorship
- Time Management
- Office Management
In addition, some institutions go into specialized areas and design tailor
made courses on specific requests of clientele.
The professional training programmes are in good demand as most employers are
looking for improved productivity by sponsoring their employees for these short
courses. These courses are aimed at refreshing the skills and to impart new
skills. The Table-1 shows the demand for some of the above courses that are
run by Centre for Continuing Education through its Extra Mural Unit. Although
the courses were offered for registration in various centres in Botswana, the
programmes were run only in Gaborone Centre due to lack of physical and human
resources. If these programmes are advertised and offered, there will be enormous
demand for the same through the country.
Table-1: Number of participants in CCE’s Professional skills programmes
Title of Course |
2002 |
2003 |
2004 |
2005 |
2006 |
Dial-a-smile |
25 |
45 |
40 |
35 |
40 |
Customer care |
35 |
40 |
50 |
45 |
50 |
Supervisory Skills |
40 |
45 |
50 |
40 |
35 |
Training of trainers |
25 |
20 |
15 |
- |
- |
Occupational Health And Safety |
- |
- |
- |
20 |
25 |
Source: Extra Mural Unit, CCE records
A similar number or even more participants were trained by other institutions
during the period and the data for other individual organizations and private
institutions is not available.
As already experienced and proved, the only way to cope with the demand and
train a huge number of people is by way of using one of the technologies of
ODL. In the process it was discovered that the concept of video conferencing
(VCf)is a viable option to offer training programmes across the country at the
same time with out compromising the quality of delivery.
VIABLE TECHNOLOGY FOR THE PROVISION OF PROFESSIONAL SKILLS
The viability of the available or future innovations will be judged
against the cost of technology, accessibility, flexibility of usage, suitability
to the situation and to the intended purpose, sustainability and finally the
adoptability by the learners and also by the distance education practitioners.
In the light of experiences with the available programmes, both from the angle
of practitioners and learners, the video-conferencing(VCf) technology is suggested
to be a viable and sustainable media of instruction for promoting professional
skills. The VCf mode suggested here has direct relevance in increasing access
to professional skills. The new technology will assist to overcome the barriers
of time and in built constraints of conventional systems.
PROVISION OF PROFESSIONAL SKILLS THROUGH ODL - A STRATEGY
Although distance education programme is not new to Botswana, the use of new
technology is a recent phenomenon. As such the role of technology in the delivery
of distance education programmes is limited. In the process of identifying suitable
mode of technology for the provision of professional skills, the video conferencing
method is proposed as a viable one. In this context, centre for continuing education
and the University of Botswana has got resources to meet the demand for the
provision of soft skills to large numbers through its four sites using video-
conferencing technology.
Video-Conferencing (VCf)
This facility at the moment is available with the CCE and Educational Technology
department. The equipment is installed through Education Democracy and Development
Initiative (EDDI) project sponsored by USA. The facility is functional and the
staff is also being trained on how to use the system and soon the facility will
be utilized for running short courses.
This facility will be extended to other places to avail flexible access unlike
face to face method. And the VCf facility would benefit masses and the number
of people with these skills in the country will increase in a short period.
Of course, the need for these skills will be there for ever as everyone wants
to upgrade/refresh their skills now and then to sustain the competition. Since
the VCf facility will be available at all four sites(CCE,Edu.Tech,Francistown
and Maun) a viable, economical and integrated services could be provided in
different places with out taking people from out of work.
Table-2 Projected Output (trained personnel)
Centre |
2006 |
2007 |
2008 |
2009 |
2010 |
CCE Gaborone |
150 |
175 |
200 |
220 |
250 |
Ed. Tech Dept., UB |
- |
40 |
60 |
80 |
100 |
Francistown |
- |
60 |
80 |
90 |
100 |
Maun |
- |
40 |
50 |
60 |
70 |
The table-2 indicates the cumulative figures for all short courses.It is projected
to train over 500 people during the year 2010with these soft skills in all programmes
put together. Further, this number will still increase when new programmes are
developed and delivered. All these programmes will be delivered through video-
conferencing. Since the equipment is already in place in all the sites, the
programmes will start as soon as possible. The provision of Professional skills
through VCf method will result in increased productivity and national economic
growth.
Way forward
Our experiences show that we can only train 20-25 participants at a time with
face to face mode of delivery. Taking advantage of 4 sites of video- conferencing,
80 participants could be trained at the same time in a particular programme
on all sites. This reduces unnecessary costs and cheaper to participants as
the overheads and direct tutor costs will be reduced.
In distance education, the use of appropriate technology will make the difference
in providing effective communication to the learners. With the suitable technology
in place, the distance education will become a high quality education in order
to overcome the resource constraints. In the present context, the VCf method
for the provision of on the job skills will emerge as one of economical method.
The demand for these courses has been increasing as the employers needed these
skills to their employees which results in increased productivity. In the present
day competitive market, especially in private sector, on the job skills are
required to maximize productivity and thereby increase their returns. Hence,
employers were never hesitant to spend on training. Further, provision of on
the job skills to the employees saves on hiring full time staff for higher emoluments
by replacing existing staff for specified periods.
As most organizations require these skills, the institutions in Botswana especially
the Centre for Continuing Education of the University of Botswana was unable
to cope with the demands through its face-to-face method. In this connection,
it is proposed to offer these skills through VCf method which would be accessed
by many people at the same time in different parts of the country.
References
- Bates, A.W. (Tony) (1995), Technology, Open Learning and Distance Education.
Routledge, London.
- Gangappa, K (2003),”Distance education through Collaboration-A Case
of Botswana,” The OSAC journal of Open Schooling Vol-III:No.-1, National
Institute of Open Schooling, New-Delhi, India
- Gangappa, K and Chandraiah, E (2004),”Responses of Learners to Technology-Based
Learning in ODL: A Case study of Dr. B. R. Ambedkar Open university,”
Indian Journal of Open Learning, IGNOU, New-Delhi, Vol-13, No.-1.
- Madhavan, K. and Manoj R. (2001), Role of Distance Education in Developing
Countries, the Indian Publications, Ambala Cantt., India.
- National Development Plans, Government of Botswana, Gaborone, Botswana
- Rastogi Satish, (1998-Ed) Educational Technology for Distance Education,
Rawat Publications, New Delhi, India.